The guilty deserve to be punished, and no moral consideration relevant to punishment outweighs the offenders criminal desert is the philosophy of retributive theory. Hegel on crime and punishment in brooks and sebastian stein eds, hegels. Hegel and the justification of realworld penal sanctions. After committing the crime, raskolnikov is overtaken by panic and tormented by conscience as, one by. I contend that a wellfunctioning criminal justice system should seek to repair the various types of physical, psychological, and normative harms caused by acts of crime, thereby restoring a. Hegels method of arriving at such answers is by no means alien to those employed by contemporary analytic philosophers. In this work, i provide an answer to this reformed question that relies on the conception of punishment articulated by hegel in his philosophy of right. It must be premised that in hegels philosophy of right the will is from the first page to the last the. Outlining her moral education theory of punishment in 1984, jean hampton mentioned hegel, along with plato, and cited j. Hegels view of crime and punishment may be gathered from the following extracts. This is in stark contrast to the space devoted to, and more ready acceptance of.
Hegel and the normative foundations of criminal justice. On the normative significance of method and system. Punishment as a threat was intended to deter crime. Published to great acclaim and fierce controversy in 1866, fyodor dostoevskys crime and punishment has left an indelible mark on global literature and our modern world, and is still known worldwide as the quintessential russian novel. The most widespread interpretation of hegel s theory of punishment is that it is retributivist, as the criminal punished is demonstrated to be deserving of a punishment commensurable in value to the severity of his crime. Hegel on punishment 171 denial or negation of the freedom and fights of the victims will. Steinberger skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Rediscovering hegels theory of crime and punishment by. Immanuel kant was emphatically in favor of the death penalty for the crime of murder, as anyone who knows anything about kant is likely to know. It is a tale set in the dingy tenements, backstreets and dramshops. Hegel on crime and punishment volume 77 issue 4 peter j. The laws of right also are simply there, and we have to become acquainted with them. Cesare bonesana di beccaria, an essay on crimes and punishments 1764 the online library of liberty this ebook pdf format is published by liberty fund, inc.
Legal punishment presupposes crime as that for which punishment is imposed, and a criminal law as that which defines crimes as crimes. This chapter offers a systematic reading of hegel s comments about punishment in his philosophical system with careful attention to his philosophy of right. The will can be coerced simply because it exists in property in. These discussions, while helpful in working through the concept of retribution, risk reducing hegels theory of punishment to just one. In recent times, the issues surrounding crime and punishment have seldom been discussed from the vantage point of political philosophy. Introduction dostoyevskys crime and punishment 1866 is based on the writers terrifying experience with summary justice and the cruel penal system of tzarist russia. Hegel s theory of crime and punishment is tested by raising against it three difficult questions. Our knowledge adds nothing to them, and does not further their operation. Hegel on crime and punishment american political science. The concepts of crime and punishment play a central role in hegels philosophy of right. Tunick also argues that hegel matters today because of his astute comments on particular topics in criminal law. Due perhaps to his frequently obscure writing style and idiosyncratic terminology, hegels account of punishment has generally not received widespread attention or a favorable reception in englishspeaking jurisprudence. Hegel s theory of crime and punishment have looked up only slightly for hegel since then.
For brooks, punishment is a response to crime which must involve a loss including a loss of liberty or money for example. In addition to epitomizing german idealist philosophy, hegel boldly claimed that his own system of philosophy represented an historical culmination of all previous philosophical thought. Hegels idea of punishment article pdf available in journal of the history of philosophy 142. A sociopsychological exploration of fyodor dostoyevskys. In hegel view, such a conception of the relationship between law, crime and punishment is undermined by insoluble problems and contradictions. Crime and punishment is a novel by fyodor dostoevsky, one of the founders of the modern novel. Hegels conception of crime and punishment pdf free download. Hegels complete views on crime and punishment request pdf. My aim is to clarify the distinctiveness of hegels project and illuminate its widely influential discussions about freedom, recognition, the individuals relation to the state and punishment to provide readers with a clear understanding of the philosophy of right within hegels philosophical system through a close reading of this text. Looks into the moral issues of a crime committed to stop another wrong being done. Hegel s method of arriving at such answers is by no means alien to those employed by contemporary analytic philosophers. These discussions, while helpful in working through the concept of retribution, risk reducing hegels theory of punishment to one elementjust within it.
Immanuel kant was emphatically in favor of the death penalty for the crime of murder, as anyone who knows anything about kant is. Hegel on crime and punishment in brooks and sebastian stein eds, hegel s political philosophy. Full text of hegels conception of crime and punishment. Hegel s view of crime and punishment may be gathered from the following extracts. Legal punishment stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Department of philosophy university of nebraskalincoln lincoln, ne 685880321, usa. He was accused of taking part in conversations against the censorship, of reading a letter from byelinsky to gogol, and of knowing of the intention to set up a printing press. Kant philosophy of murder warrants death sentences as not acceptable to the modern civilized society. One of these problems is that this juridical model of justice, he believes, is unable to generate the terms of a possible reconciliation between the punished criminal and the violated law. The will can be coerced simply because it exists in property in order to manifest its freedom. This is in stark contrast to the space devoted to, and more ready acceptance of, hegels. Crime, as an aspect of what is right, is never something purely subjective.
Hegel on crime and punishment in brooks and sebastian stein eds, hegels political philosophy. Jurisprudence of crime and punishment from plato to hegel. Readers of all backgrounds have debated its historical, cultural, and spiritual dimensions, probing the moral. Crime, punishment, existentialism, psychoanalysis, dostoyvesky. In its execution, however, the state was limited in its reaction by a retributive theory of justice demanding respect for the individual as an end and not as a means to some further social. The concepts of crime and punishment play a central role in hegel s philosophy of right. Request pdf hegels complete views on crime and punishment in this article, i argue that hegels complete and mature view of crime and. This does not mean that the punishment frightens him from offending. Dostoevskys hegelian parody in crime and punishment. Mctaggarts 1896 article on hegels theory of punishment. Crime and punishment a christian view of dostoevskys. Punishment aspires to be a cancellation of a crime and its illeffects in a restoration of right restoring rights violated by a crime pr, 99. Feuerbach would make of man a slave, while hegel asserts that in punishment the criminal is treated as truly rational.
If crime were only a side of an act, it would not be possible to pass, as hegel does, from an analysis of crime to the punishment of the criminal. Hegel is clear that punishment is only justified where it is deserved by an offender for committing a crime. The second of these further advantages of punishment is the reformation of the criminal. Crime and punishment 1866 perhaps the greatest of all psychological crime novels. Mctaggarts 1896 article on hegel s theory of punishment. The graver the crime, the more severe the deserved punishment. Hegel on crime and punishment cambridge university press. As the first moment in which the notion of right truly encounters an other, crime is thus the. In a letter describing his plan to write crime and punishment, he said, punishment meted out by the law to the criminal deters the criminal far less than the lawgivers think he believed that in order for punishment to work, it had to make the criminal accept his own guilt. A more indepth reading of both hegels history of philosophy and dostoevskys crime and punishment reveals that not only do jones claims fail to refute the connection, but that they actually aid his opponents arguments. Jun, 2018 hegel offers us comments about punishment that support this interpretation. I contend that a wellfunctioning criminal justice system should seek to repair the various types of physical, psychological, and normative harms caused by acts of crime, thereby restoring a particular community to its pre crime state. The knowledge of right is partly of the same nature and partly different.
Criminal justice is distinctive in that it is the demand for a justice freed from subjective interest and a subjective form and no longer contingent on power, i. Jones cites three specific differences between the two texts, including the role and ideas of heroes. Hegel offers us comments about punishment that support this interpretation. Object of punishment is not only punishing the criminal but to prevent the crime in future also. The jurisprudence of crime and punishment from plato to hegel, the american journal of jurisprudence, volume 39, issue 1, 1 january 1994, pa. I contend that a wellfunctioning criminal justice system should seek to repair the various types of physical, psychological, and normative harms caused by acts of crime, thereby restoring a particular community to its precrime state. Hegels theory of crime and punishment have looked up only slightly for hegel since then. Georg wilhelm friedrich hegel 17701831 is one of the greatest systematic thinkers in the history of western philosophy. I understand punishment not as an act in which the. If he welcomed imprisonment or death gladly, they would cease to be a punishment, but they would be equally preventive of crime. This novel deals with the question of responsibility for the actions of each individual, background of struggle between god, morality and the theory of the superman. Raskolnikov, a student, decides to kill a worthless person to help his impoverished family, and to prove that he is exempt from moral law. Punishment and the state in early modern europe 26 2. The severity of the crime is a function of the relative importance of the reasons we have to dissuade people from committing it, reasons that will make reference to harms done to victims, to social relationships.
The answer also reflects the fact that teaching fellow, fas, harvard univ. In crime and punishment, fyodor dostoevsky relates the story of rodion raskolnikov, a man who murders a pawnbroker in st. Hegels theory of punishment thus frequently focus on his claim that punishment cancels or annuls the crime. Social and political thought internet encyclopedia. According to the retributive theory the purpose of punishment is to seek revenge. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. Hegel, too, thinks of punishment as the inevitable sequel of crime, although, on the other hand, he finds in punishment not a menace but the necessary completion of the criminals deed. Deals with the inner struggles and conflicts of the one doing wrong. It was a tool in the hands of civil society to counteract human drives toward violating anothers rights. This chapter offers a systematic reading of hegels comments about punishment in his philosophical system with careful attention to his philosophy of right. Crime and punishment planet publish free pdf ebooks. Pdf hegel on crime and punishment thom brooks academia. Punitive severity must accord with the relative severity of the crime.
It argues that the conventional reading, which claims his theory of punishment is mostly confined to the section abstract right, raises interpretive difficulties. Retributive theory is based on rights, desert and justice. Instead, they have tended to become the province of lawyers, psychologists, and specialists in ethics or the philosophy of language. However, he only refers to punishment as imprisonment and does not. Hegels theory of crime and punishment is tested by raising against it three difficult questions. Of the various theories of punishment the following there are the most important and typical retributive, preventive and reformative. Capital punishment has in consequence become rarer, as in fact should be the case with this most extreme punishment. Crime and punishment translators preface a few words about dostoevsky himself may help the english reader to understand his work. Crime and punishment tells the story of redemption. It must be premised that in hegels philosophy of right the. His parents were very hard working and deeply religious people, but so poor that they lived with their five children in only two rooms.
1068 1191 512 219 1533 405 270 93 1217 432 267 784 1090 1025 1152 1244 704 807 1322 766 506 533 318 439 1520 152 367 1532 181 1366 519 663 380 1566 1207 460 1074 671 876 1354 1333 1436 1449 195 190 685 111